Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Apology Not Needed

After my comment on the front page photo of the Sunday Star Times, a reader hiding behind "Anonymous" said...

Hey, just wondering when you're going to apologise to the photographer. It wasn't a jack-up at all ... the girl has been quoted as saying she wanted to "play in the earthquake" and the photographer got lucky. If your gonna dish dirt you shld have the grace to apologise - September 13, 2010 8:12 PM

I did a search and discovered that the Sunday Star Times published a follow-up to the story saying:

"LITTLE MYRO McKee became the face of the Sunday Star-Times earthquake coverage when she featured on the front page last weekend.

The five-year-old was pictured in the rubble by Christchurch photographer Jane Wyles, a shot that prompted some readers to complain it was staged or sensationalised. It was neither."





According to the paper,

"She says the family sheltered under a table at the time of the quake but she was allowed out later in the morning, when Wyles photographed her in the rubble outside her nana's Sydenham home. "I was looking at all the earthquakes," she says

Call me silly, but look at that picture again; does that rubble look like it was from a "home"? And with all the after shocks, why was a little girl allowed to "play" in the rubble?

Oh... actually she was "looking at all the earthquakes." ;)

Assuming little Myro was looking at the rubble when the photographer saw her and she was asked to squat among the fallen bricks for that shot; that technically is still a JACK UP photo.

Sorry, Mr / Miss "Anonymous"; no apology needed!

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Comments so far....

Huggies (not his real name), a close friend and a Picture editor commented on my link.

Huggies wrote

"CY , I agree with you. How can there not be a better pic when it is the most jialat (the worst) earthquake in decades? Their worry shd be, are there enough pages to use the most touching pictures.

The problem is most newsroom are run like paper mill.

As I always said "We are the Unwilling ,Ruled by the Unknowing ,
to do the Unfulfilling and Work for the Ungrateful"
September 14, 2010 12:42 PM
--------------------------------------------------
Anonymous said...

All thats missing from that Photo is that the girl isn't holding a Doll with a torn dress! September 14, 2010 1:06 PM
--------------------------------------------------
CH Loh,my protégé and well known photojournalist in Malaysia commented on my link via Facebook:

Loh wrote

"Definitely it was a staged picture, if I was the photographer I will ask her to hold some toys and look through the rubble with her parents that will be more meaningful! Not posing like this, CY, why should you apologise? You are just pointing out the mistake created by the Sunday-Star Times photographer, they should thank you for pointing up their serious mistake...:) :)"
September 14, 2010 8:33 PM
--------------------------------------------------
heather said...

"Yeah Right!" It would make a good Tui ad! How did it get past the photo editor? Such pose!
September 15, 2010 11:34 AM
--------------------------------------------------



The Plot Thickens! You Might Also Like:

STILL NO APOLOGY NEEDED!!

15 comments:

cy.leow said...

Huggies (not his real name), a close friend and a Picture editor commented on my link.

Huggies wrote

"CY , I agree with you. How can there not be a better pic when it is the most jialat earthquake in decades? Their worry shd be, are there enough pages to use the most touching pictures.

The problem is most newsroom are run like paper mill.

As I always said "We are the Unwilling ,Ruled by the Unknowing ,
to do the Unfulfilling and Work for the Ungrateful"

Anonymous said...

All thats missing from that Photo is that the girl isn't holding a Doll with a torn dress

cy.leow said...

CH Loh,my protégé and well known photojournalist in Malaysia commented on my link via Facebook:

Loh wrote

"Definitely it was a staged picture, if I was the photographer I will ask her to hold some toys and look through the rubble with her parents that will be more meaningful! Not posing like this, CY, why should you apologise? You are just pointing out the mistake created by the Sunday-Star Times photographer, they should thank you for pointing up their serious mistake...:) :)"

heather said...

"Yeah Right!" It would make a good Tui ad! How did it get past the photo editor?i. Such pose!

cy.leow said...

I am sure the Photo Editor love that shot too ;)

Sista Sarah said...

Actually not posed at all. My sister is the photographer and described to me coming across the girl, so you're all talking through a hole in your head. And yes it does look like someone's home- if you know Sydenham at all you'd know that much of it is row houses of old brick buildings- no doubt little of it still standing after the last quake- amazes me the pettiness of some people in this world.

Sista Sarah said...

The photographer is about the most genuine person you could meet and does not do staged photos.

cy.leow said...

I am sure she is a genuine person,if that picture is not posed then it is a REALLY BAD news photograph. All my friends (many who are in the media industry) who saw the picture think it was posed.
I suppose the Picture Editor should be fired for using this picture on the front page.
Personally I felt there are other better news pictures for that event!
I know what I am talking about because I have been a Picture Editor most of my working life.
So stop getting all work up and get on with life ;)

Sista Sarah said...

Maybe there were other pictures more appropriate but to have someone fired?? Strong words. Of course I should have realized how superior you are to the rest of us from your initial post. I am getting on with my life BTW, supporting my family and friends in Christchurch and not being a complete ... Maybe you could do or say something with a positive impact and a happy heart instead.

Sista Sarah said...

I'm not sure that I agree with you that a kid playing in rubble is a bad news story either- I'm sure there are countless opportunities for such photos today in Christchurch. It's been rumbling there for 5 months now so that is their reality- a very sad one with long term impact.

Jane Wyles said...

Hi
It is Jane Wyles here. I am the photographer of the image! Thank you for your comments, and thank you darling sis for your support! Let me just briefly put this straight. I ventured out in a terrified state on the day after the earthquake just locally to where I live. I came across Myro playing amongst the bricks (her parents there of course and she was safe and happy). I took a photographic opportunity of this gorgeous girl who herself said "she was looking at the earthquake". I was NOT a set up, sure it looked third world but it wasn't, it was Sydenham, Christchurch! As the editor and I saw, it, it was a human element that gave a bit of light after such a tramatic event! Now, there are images of bodies being pulled out of rubble, blood smeared faces, some of now are dead! Would you rather see these images? Or of our whole home down in ruins? You obviously have no idea of how tragic this is for all here. Life has changed for us and what is important takes on a new meaning. Save the Children Fund want to use the image in a TV ad so I thank those of you that had something positive to say. As for the Editor being fired ... really? I see this as bitter in your work! The parents, the newspaper and myself are proud of the photo so I will hold onto that.
Thanks for your time.
Cheers
Jane

CY Blog fan said...

CY was commenting on his opinion of the photo as a very experienced photojourno and photoeditor thats all. Personally the photo doesn't really "strike a cord" for me either just a personal thing really.

heather said...

Gratuitous is the word!This is a photo of damage to shops and she was put there to make the photo appear more sensational.There is nothing natural about this photo! Anyone can see that!

cy.leow said...

My response, lets end this silly feud; no more!

http://cyleow.blogspot.com/2011/03/wednesday-23-march-2011-it-started-with.html

sc goh said...

Only fit for a "photo-album"....